Episodes

Join Kyle and Nate as they dive into the enigmatic case of Maura Murray, a 21-year-old nursing student who mysteriously disappeared in New Hampshire in 2004 shortly after wrecking her car on a snowy road. This episode delves into the circumstances surrounding her disappearance, exploring theories r...

If The United States were a 90’s sitcom, the state of Florida would be known for nothing if not being the Kramer of states; a kooky neighbor who is always getting into something wacky. But for the better part of a century, Floridians from all over the state have reported seeing a strange, giant a...

Bigger. Better. BOLDER. More Bigfoot. More King of the Hill. More of the Universe's Greatest Mysteries. You will be SHOCKED and HORRIFIED by what you hear next.

What if your dream home turned into your worst nightmare home? For the Broaddus family, their 2014 purchase of 657 Boulevard in Westfield, New Jersey, turned into nothing short of a shared nightmare. Just days after purchasing their idyllic new home, the Broaddus family began to receive a s...

In December 1968, Tokyo witnessed a crime that continues to baffle authorities, armchair detectives, and neckbeards nearly 60 years later. A cunning young man decided that the world was his, and hatched a genius plan – a plan so bold, that some would even call it stupid. However, its brazen natur...

Due to simultaneous busy schedules, we need to pause the show for a couple of weeks. But don't fret, Dear Listener! We'll be back again to breathe new life into an old mystery on June 24. --- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/nate3901/message

Deep within the swampy jungles of Central Africa lurks a legend: Mokele-mbembe. This name, translating roughly to "one who stops the flow of rivers" in the Lingala language, refers to a creature said to inhabit the Congo Basin. Described as a monstrous, long-necked sauropod, Mokele-mbembe...

Join Kyle and Nate in an unedited, off-the-cuff special VIDEO episode as they revisit episodes 21 - 30 and discuss how their thoughts have changed, if at all, and add more thoughts to each mystery. For the video version of this episode, use the Spotify app OR head on over to our YouTube channel...

In August of 1993, the hit television series Mighty Morphin' Power Rangers dropped on the Fox Kids network and took America's youth by storm. Toys, Halloween costumes, and other merchandise were flying off the shelves, and the creators of the show were flyin' high. To this day, the se...